Kanye West Defeated In Legal Battle Over ‘Hurricane’ Sample Use

image

Kanye West has officially lost a copyright trial connected to an uncleared sample used during an early performance of his song Hurricane.

The decision came after West, who also goes by Ye, testified in court that he knowingly removed the sample from the track after the listening event because he did not have permission to use it legally.

On Tuesday afternoon, a jury of eight unanimously ruled that Ye infringed on the copyright of an unreleased demo by using part of it in an early version of Hurricane, which was played in front of 40,000 fans during a sold out event five years ago.

The court ordered West personally to pay $176,153 (£130,137), while several of his associated companies were found liable for an additional $262,045 (£193,592).

Artists Revenue Advocates manager Britton Monts, whose company filed the lawsuit on behalf of the four musicians behind the original sample, described the outcome as an important moment for smaller artists.

Speaking to Rolling Stone, Monts said: "It's a victory for working artists, who typically lack the resources to go against someone like Ye, a megastar and celebrity.

"The underdogs got their day in court.”

A spokesperson for Yeezy pushed back against the ruling and framed the result differently, saying: "This is a failed shakedown. Six months ago, they wanted $30 million (£22 million).

"The moral of the story? There is a cost attached to thinking you can take advantage of Ye.”

During the six day trial, lawyers representing ARA argued that West generated approximately $5.6 million (£4.14 million) through ticket sales from the July 2021 listening event in Atlanta, along with merchandise revenue and a streaming agreement with Apple Music.

The final version of Hurricane, which featured The Weeknd and Lil Baby, later won the Grammy Awards award for Best Melodic Rap Performance.

The lawsuit adds to a long list of copyright disputes West has faced throughout his career over allegations of unauthorized sampling. However, this marked the first time one of those cases actually went to trial.

COMMENTS

Leave a comment

Eric Church Performs ‘Carolina’ During UNC-Chapel Hill Graduation Speech

image

Eric Church delivered more than just a graduation speech at UNC-Chapel Hill on Saturday (May 10). The country star turned the university’s commencement ceremony into a heartfelt musical lesson, performing “Carolina” while sharing an emotional message with the graduating class of 2026.

Church admitted that putting together the speech did not come easily. Speaking in front of more than 7,000 graduates gathered at Kenan Stadium in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, the singer revealed that he abandoned several versions of his remarks before finally realizing he needed to approach it through music.

“I have torn up multiple speeches,” said Church, who has earned two Billboard 200 chart topping albums along with several No. 1 and No. 2 projects on the Top Country Albums chart. “I have thrown things. And in one of my fits of frustration, I sat down with a guitar. And I thought, man, who am I kidding. I need to figure out a way to do this with a guitar.”

The Granite Falls, North Carolina native opened his speech with a metaphor centered around an out of tune guitar. “I want to start with a sound,” he told the graduates. “You know this sound. It’s a guitar that’s out of tune — something that almost gets there, it tries, but doesn’t. Some ancient, honest part of your brain knows it immediately. You don’t need training to hear it. You just know. That sound is the sound of something beautiful that has not been tended to.”

Church then expanded the idea into a life lesson built around the six strings of a guitar. “Six strings. When all six are in tune, the chords they make can stop a conversation cold, carry a broken person through the worst night of their life, or make a room full of strangers feel for three minutes like they’ve known each other forever,” he explained. “But if even one is off, the whole chord unravels. Not gradually, not politely. The moment you strike it you know. I believe your life runs on this principle.”

Throughout the address, Church connected each guitar string to a different pillar of life, including faith, family, heart, ambition and resilience, community, and personal identity. He encouraged the graduating class — made up of 4,453 undergraduate students, 1,608 master’s students, and 981 doctoral students — to chase their ambitions while staying grounded in the communities and values that shaped them.

“I want you to want things. You should want things,” Church told the crowd. “The world has more than enough people standing at the edge of their own potential waiting for a permission slip that was never gonna arrive. Want the thing. Say it out loud. Build toward it with everything you have.”

At the same time, he warned students about losing themselves in a world built around visibility and online validation. “Your generation faces a temptation no generation before has ever faced,” he said. “The temptation to perform to everyone and belong to no one. To be globally visible and locally invisible. To have thousands of followers and no one knows actually where you live. Resist it. Plant yourself somewhere.”

Church continued by urging students to embrace their individuality rather than blending into the crowd. “You were made uniquely, wonderfully, distinctly,” he said. “There’s a sound only you can make. A voice that has never existed before you and will never exist again. The world does not need another cover song. It needs an original.”

As the speech continued, Church returned to his six string metaphor, reminding graduates that every part of life will eventually drift out of balance. “Your faith will go quiet when you need it loud,” he explained. “Your family will get complicated. Your ambition will hollow out and your resilience will wear thin. This is not failure. This is not weakness.”

“The difference between a life that sounds like music and a life that sounds like noise is whether you stop and listen,” he added. “Whether you’re honest enough to hear which string has drifted out of tune, humble enough to make the adjustment instead of just turning up the volume and hoping nobody notices.”

Naturally, the moment would not have been complete without music. Church closed out the ceremony with a performance of “Carolina,” the title track from his 2009 album, as graduates linked arms and swayed together throughout the stadium.

Church joins a growing list of artists delivering commencement speeches this year, alongside fellow country stars Riley Green and Luke Combs, while Hilary Duff recently addressed graduates at Northeastern University.

COMMENTS

Leave a comment